Outrageous. Extracts from the lengthy piece:
Regular viewers of Songs Of Praise might remember ‘inspirational bell-ringer’ Julie McDonnell. She appeared on the BBC show on Easter Sunday, 2016, when she spoke movingly about undergoing a stem cell transplant to overcome terminal blood cancer which had inspired her to launch a campaign to help others with the life-threatening condition.
A special peal devised by fellow ringers — the ‘Julie McDonnell Doubles — was rung at her local church, historic St George’s in Brede, East Sussex, with members of the congregation asked to make a donation to raise public awareness about leukaemia…
What happened next sent shockwaves through the bell-ringing community. Julie McDonnell was arrested and later charged with the theft of £5,840 from the JustGiving platform, money donated via the fundraising site, which should have gone to cancer charities.
How much her campaign, which received local and national Press coverage, raised in total is not known but the indictment referred solely to donations, typically £5, £10 or £20, from scores of decent people around the country who just wanted to contribute something to a worthwhile cause…
On March 20, 2019, Julie McDonnell entered a plea of not guilty at Hastings Magistrates’ Court. A seemingly straightforward prosecution, however, has dragged on interminably, with the defendant sometimes unable to attend court because she claimed she was suffering from multiple conditions including muscle weakness, PTSD, neurological problems, an eating disorder, and failing mental health which has, most recently, rendered her apparently mute. Now, four years on, there have been two sensational twists in this already extraordinary story.
Last week, after at least 20 hearings, seven different judges and two sets of solicitors, with the taxpayer footing the bill, the theft charge against McDonnell was dropped at Lewes Crown Court and a formal verdict of ‘not guilty’ entered because it was decided there was little prospect, in the circumstances, of the case ever going to trial — even though a succession of the aforementioned judges suspected McDonnell was malingering, ‘playing the system’, to quote one.
The bell-ringing campaign, it can also be revealed, was also based on a lie. Police discovered that Julie McDonnell had never undergone a stem cell transplant and could not, therefore, have been ‘matched’ with a compatible donor by the Anthony Nolan charity, as she had claimed.
That revelation emerged at a previous hearing but went unreported.
On Friday of last week, just hours after the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) withdrew from the case, Julie McDonnell posted a picture of herself on Facebook grinning like a Cheshire cat. You couldn’t make it up, could you? A CPS spokesperson said the service had been ‘trial-ready’ since late 2019 but ‘given that these allegations date back to 2016 and it has so far not been possible to bring the case to trial, we were asked by the judge to review the case and decide whether it was in the public interest to continue. Following that review and having applied that legal test, we reluctantly decided it was no longer in the public interest to continue with the prosecution.’
If you’d like email notifications of our new blog pieces, please enter your email address in the box near the top of the right-hand column and click ‘Subscribe’.
Our YouTube channel is
here, our Facebook channel
here, our Twitter channel
here.
If everyone who reads this gives us £5.00 – or even better, £5.00 or more, monthly – we could change the world. You can support our work by making a donation
here.