Freya Bromley’s piece for ‘The Huffington Post’ on the Durham debate

Freya Bromley is a student at Durham University, and a HuffPo contributor. She was most helpful in sorting out the arrangements for last Friday’s debate at Durham University. She’s just published a piece on the debate:

http://www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/freya-bromley/feminism-debate_b_4666788.html

Her piece is predictably feminist-friendly, it has to be said, and my own view of the event is very different. I was delighted by the rapt attention given to my arguments and Swayne O’Pie’s by the overwhelming majority of the capacity audience (300 people, mainly students). We were originally told to expect a demonstration outside the debate venue by members of the Durham University Feminist Society – presumably referred to as ‘duffers’ – but were reliably informed the demonstration had been called off because… er… it was raining lightly.

The J4MB supporters at the event were pleased at the talks given by Swayne O’Pie and myself, and the audience’s response to them. We always knew we couldn’t possibly win the vote – the audience mostly consisted of women, some angry gender feminists among them – but the support we did get for the motion was well in excess of what we’d anticipated. We also met plenty of students after the debate – both men and women – who were highly supportive.

Being pushed for time, I’ve limited the comments I’ve posted in response to Freya’s piece to the following, which has already been published. The ‘Justice for Women’ URL I refer to is http://www.justiceforwomen.org.uk:

Freya, thanks for this, and for arranging a very interesting evening. My thanks too, to all the people Swayne and I met afterwards.

I’m very pushed for time, but just want to raise one issue. The last URL in your piece takes people to the ‘Justice for Women’ website which I claimed in my talk had the strapline, ‘Men, women and murder’. Ms Bindel shouted, ‘Lie!’ or ‘Liar!’, and later said to me this wasn’t the organisation she co-founded, and that there were a number of organisations with the same name in the UK. We’ve been unable to find any. Would you please be so good as to ask Ms Bindel for the URL of the organisation she’s referring to, or a retraction of the allegation that I lied? Thank you.

3 thoughts on “Freya Bromley’s piece for ‘The Huffington Post’ on the Durham debate

  1. I went to the Justice for Women website and it says it was founded in 1990:
    http://www.justiceforwomen.org.uk/about-us/

    This article states Bindel co-founded Justice for women in 1990:
    http://article.wn.com/view/2013/09/25/Feminist_campaigner_and_journalist_Julie_Bindel_joins_Brunel/

    The site also links to at least 4 articles written by Bindel, all of which also mention Justice for Women
    http://www.justiceforwomen.org.uk/coverage/

    It would appear she’s talking complete nonsense (as usual).

    Like

  2. To be fair to Ms. Bromley she does suggest the vote was influenced by the speakers styles as much as arguments. Cindy Gallop appears to have put entertainment over coherence. At least from the report.
    And well done to you and Mr Opie. It hopeful to see such a debate take place .

    Like

    • Thanks. I honestly couldn’t see how Ms Gallop’s piece related to the motion – it was shameless self-promotion, in the main – while Ms Bindel’s piece was long on emotion and anecdote, and short on factual evidence.

      Like

Leave a comment